| 2023-2024 Individual Honors |
| Sebastian Del Toro | | Senior |
| Named Monterey Bay League Santa Lucia Division Most Valuable Player. All Monterey Bay League Santa Lucia Division selection. |
|
| Alex Heyermann | | Senior |
| All Monterey Bay League Santa Lucia Division selection. |
|
| 2022-2023 Individual Honors |
| Sebastian Del Toro | | Junior |
| All Monterey Bay League Santa Lucia Division selection. |
|
| Tristan Pfleger | | Senior |
| All Monterey Bay League Santa Lucia Division selection. |
|
| 2021-2022 Individual Honors |
| Tyler Dwelle | | Senior |
| All Pacific Coast Athletic League Arroyo Division selection. |
|
| Jason Khan | | Senior |
| All Pacific Coast Athletic League Arroyo Division selection. |
|
| Ryan Krageland | | Senior |
| All Pacific Coast Athletic League Arroyo Division selection. |
|
| 2018-2019 Individual Honors |
| Max Burke | | Senior |
| All Pacific Coast Athletic League (Santa Lucia Division) selection. |
|
| Navid Daliri | | Senior |
| All Pacific Coast Athletic League (Santa Lucia Division) selection. |
|
| 2016-2017 Individual Honors |
| Navid Daliri | | Sophomore |
| All Mission Trail Athletic League Coastal Division selection. |
|
| 2015-2016 Individual Honors |
| William Calciano | | Senior |
| All Mission Trail Athletic League Coastal Division selection. |
|
| Marcos Diaz-Infante | | Senior |
| All Mission Trail Athletic League Coastal Division selection. |
|
| Andrew Johnson | | Junior |
| All Mission Trail Athletic League Coastal Division selection. |
|
| 2012-2013 Individual Honors |
| Ryan Ixtlahuac | | Freshman |
| All Mission Trail Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2011-2012 Individual Honors |
| Jonathan DeAnda | Defender | Senior |
| All Mission Trail Athletic League selection. |
|
| Tizoc Franco | Defender | Senior |
| All Mission Trail Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2010-2011 Individual Honors |
| Perry Choi | | Senior |
| All Mission Trail Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2009-2010 Individual Honors |
| Will Campodonico | | Senior |
| All Coastal Athletic League selection. |
|
| Harrison Mace | | Senior |
| All Coastal Athletic League selection. |
|
| Wilson Mefford | | Senior |
| All Coastal Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2008-2009 Individual Honors |
| Matt Lee | | Senior |
| All Coastal Athletic League selection. |
|
| Nolan Pura | | Senior |
| All Coastal Athletic League selection. |
|
| Jon Steck | | Senior |
| All Coastal Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2007-2008 Individual Honors |
| Matt Lee | Defender | Junior |
| All Coastal Athletic League selection. |
|
| Nolan Pura | Forward | Junior |
| All Coastal Athletic League selection. |
|
| Jon Steck | Halfback | Junior |
| All Coastal Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2006-2007 Individual Honors |
| Matt Lee | Defender | Sophomore |
| All Mission Trail Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2004-2005 Individual Honors |
| Lea Ochoa | Forward | Senior |
| All Mission Trail Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2003-2004 Individual Honors |
| Colin Fyfe | Midfielder | Sophomore |
| All Mission Trail Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2002-2003 Individual Honors |
| Lea Ochoa | Midfielder | Sophomore |
| All Mission Trail Athletic League selection. |
|