| 2023-2024 Individual Honors |
| Aiden Nounnan | Midfielder | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2022-2023 Individual Honors |
| Aiden Nounnan | | Junior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2016-2017 Individual Honors |
| Blake Kuehl | Goalkeeper | Junior |
| Named Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League Goalkeeper of the Year. |
|
| Max Stein | Defender | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2015-2016 Individual Honors |
| Mitchell Kamau | Midfield | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Blake Kuehl | Goalkeeper | Sophomore |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| George Palau | Defender | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2014-2015 Individual Honors |
| Mitchell Kamau | Midfielder | Junior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Garrett Kustin | Goalkeeper | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2013-2014 Individual Honors |
| Garrett Kustin | Goalkeeper | Junior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2012-2013 Individual Honors |
| Carter Hayes | Defender | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Ben Knudson | Defender | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2011-2012 Individual Honors |
| Nick Calabray | | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Ben Knudson | | Junior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Cameron Morse | | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2010-2011 Individual Honors |
| David Kamau | Midfield | N/A |
| Named Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League Midfielder of the Year. |
|
| Alex Lopez | | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Thomas McIntosh | | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Alex Rinkert | | N/A |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2009-2010 Individual Honors |
| David Kamau | | N/A |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Thomas McIntosh | Defender | Junior |
| Named Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League Defender of the Year. |
|
| Nathan Wood | | Junior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2008-2009 Individual Honors |
| David Kamau | | N/A |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Will Lawton | | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2007-2008 Individual Honors |
| Michael Eisner | Forward | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2006-2007 Individual Honors |
| Kellen Coffis | | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Peter Kent-Stoll | | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Jeremy Shriver-Munsch | Goalkeeper | Junior |
| Named Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League Goalkeeper of the Year. All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Alden Wood | | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2005-2006 Individual Honors |
| Eric Ove | Defender | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2004-2005 Individual Honors |
| Skylar Storey | Forward | Junior |
| All Santa Cruz County Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2002-2003 Individual Honors |
| Jamie Coffis | Midfielder | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz County Athletic League selection. |
|