| 2023-2024 Individual Honors |
| Matthias Cruz | | Junior |
| Named Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League Defensive Player of the Year. All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Hayden Johnson | | Sophomore |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. Named to the All-Central Coast Section Boys Water Polo Honorable Mention Team. |
|
| Pakalani Vaka-Saxton | | Junior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Tate Wilson | | Junior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2021-2022 Individual Honors |
| David Culver | | Junior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Kai Owens | | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2019-2020 Individual Honors |
| Quinn Cury | | N/A |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Lachlan Nagel | | Junior |
| Named Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League Most Valuable Player. All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Zach Wagner-Jauregg | | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2018-2019 Individual Honors |
| Sam Culver | | Senior |
| All Pacific Coast Athletic League (Gabilan Division) selection. |
|
| Zach Wagner-Jauregg | | Junior |
| All Pacific Coast Athletic League (Gabilan Division) selection. |
|
| 2017-2018 Individual Honors |
| Lee Hildinger | | Senior |
| Named Monterey Bay League Gabilan Division Co-Most Valuable Player. All Monterey Bay League Gabilan Division selection. |
|
| Logan Jackson | | Senior |
| All Monterey Bay League Gabilan Division selection. |
|
| Thomas Trenholme | | Senior |
| All Monterey Bay League Gabilan Division selection. |
|
| 2016-2017 Individual Honors |
| Sam Culver | | Sophomore |
| Named Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) Sophomore of the Year. |
|
| Lee Hildinger | | Junior |
| Named Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) Junior of the Year. All Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) selection. |
|
| Jack Radovan | | Senior |
| All Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) selection. |
|
| Zach Wagner-Jauregg | | Freshman |
| Named Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) Freshman of the Year. |
|
| 2015-2016 Individual Honors |
| Carter Baginski | 2M/DR/2MD | Senior |
| Named Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) Most Valuable Player. All Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) selection. |
|
| Ellis Boisvert | Goalkeeper | Senior |
| All Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) selection. |
|
| Gabe Discipulo | 2MD | Freshman |
| All Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) selection. |
|
| Isaiah Discipulo | 2MD/DR | Senior |
| Named Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) Freshman of the Year. All Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) selection. |
|
| Logan Jackson | DR | Sophomore |
| Named Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) Sophomore of the Year. |
|
| Jack Radovan | DR/2MD | Junior |
| All Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) selection. |
|
| 2014-2015 Individual Honors |
| Carter Baginski | | Junior |
| Named Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) Junior of the Year. All Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) selection. |
|
| Isaiah Discipulo | | Junior |
| All Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) selection. |
|
| Lee Hildinger | | Freshman |
| Named Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) Freshman of the Year. |
|
| 2013-2014 Individual Honors |
| Liam Barry | | Junior |
| All Monterey Bay League (Gabilan Division) selection. |
|
| Scott Dettmeier | | N/A |
| All Monterey Bay League (Gabilan Division) selection. |
|
| 2012-2013 Individual Honors |
| Turner Roll | Driver | Senior |
| All Monterey Bay League Gabilan Division selection. |
|
| Alex Waggoner | 2M | Senior |
| All Monterey Bay League Gabilan Division selection. |
|
| 2011-2012 Individual Honors |
| Alex Waggoner | 2m | Junior |
| All Tri County Athletic League (Mountain) selection. |
|
| 2009-2010 Individual Honors |
| Cole Garner | | Junior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2008-2009 Individual Honors |
| Andy Scott | | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2007-2008 Individual Honors |
| Michael Putnum-Pite | | Freshman |
| Named Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League Freshman of the Year. |
|
| Andy Scott | | Junior |
| Named Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League Junior of the Year. All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|