| 2023-2024 Individual Honors |
| Gabriel Suarez-Abraham | | Freshman |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2017-2018 Individual Honors |
| Cameron Wagner | | N/A |
| All Monterey Bay League Gabilan Division selection. |
|
| 2016-2017 Individual Honors |
| Eric Tallman | | N/A |
| All Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) selection. |
|
| Jordan Tallman | | N/A |
| All Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) selection. |
|
| 2015-2016 Individual Honors |
| Alex Stratton | | Senior |
| All Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) selection. |
|
| Eric Tallman | | N/A |
| All Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) selection. |
|
| 2014-2015 Individual Honors |
| Alex Stratton | | Junior |
| All Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) selection. |
|
| Eric Tallman | | N/A |
| Named Monterey Bay League (Gabilan) Co-Sophomore of the Year. |
|
| 2013-2014 Individual Honors |
| Nick Guzman | | Senior |
| All Monterey Bay League (Gabilan Division) selection. |
|
| Alex Stratton | | Sophomore |
| Named Monterey Bay League (Gabilan Division) Sophomore of the Year . All Monterey Bay League (Gabilan Division) selection. |
|
| 2012-2013 Individual Honors |
| Nick Guzman | Goalkeeper | Junior |
| All Monterey Bay League Gabilan Division selection. |
|
| 2011-2012 Individual Honors |
| Tanner Gilbert | Driver | Senior |
| All Tri County Athletic League (Mountain) selection. |
|
| Jack Pickard | Driver | Freshman |
| All Tri County Athletic League (Mountain) selection. |
|
| Ian Weckler | Driver | Senior |
| All Tri County Athletic League (Mountain) selection. |
|
| 2009-2010 Individual Honors |
| Cody Gilbert | | Senior |
| Named Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League Senior of the Year. All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. Named by the San Jose Mercury to the All-Central Coast Section Boys Water Polo Second Team. |
|
| Troy Smith | Goalkeeper | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Brian Tully | | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2008-2009 Individual Honors |
| Cody Gilbert | | Junior |
| Named Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League Junior of the Year. All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. Named by the San Jose Mercury to the All-Central Coast Section Boys Water Polo Honorable Mention Team. |
|
| Troy Smith | Goalkeeper | Junior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| Kris Strunk | | Senior |
| All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|
| 2007-2008 Individual Honors |
| Cody Gilbert | Hole Set | Sophomore |
| Named Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League Sophomore of the Year. All Santa Cruz Coast Athletic League selection. |
|